Strategy & Growth

Quote and Proposal Win Rates: What the Numbers Actually Show

Proposal statistics come almost entirely from proposal-software vendors, and the best-known one, the "2x within 24 hours" table, has no source we could open. Here is what the real datasets count, what the pricing research does and does not prove, and how to measure your own quotes.

oToK Team14 min read
Quote and Proposal Win Rates: What the Numbers Actually Show

Not legal advice: Nearly every number below is vendor-reported (proposal software companies and one RFP-software company), and none is an audited sample of Israeli small businesses. The legal points describe what the statutes say, not legal advice: for a specific quote, ask a lawyer. The funnel example uses made-up numbers; replace them with your own.

Search for quote or proposal win rates and you will meet the same few claims: send the proposal within 24 hours and you win about twice as often, the average close rate is somewhere between 20% and 45%, and video, interactive pricing or an e-signature each add double-digit lifts. They are repeated as if they came from independent research. They do not. Almost all of them come from companies that sell proposal software, measured on proposals sent through their own platforms.

We went to the vendors' own pages and reports (Proposify's 2026 State of Proposals, Better Proposals' annual reports, DIGIDECK's open-tracking data, Loopio's 2026 RFP report) and to the peer-reviewed work on how a price should be presented: the decoy-effect replications, a 2025 meta-analysis of first-offer anchoring and a large field experiment on offer deadlines. We also read what the Israeli Contracts Law and Consumer Protection Law say about a quote. The short version: a typical win rate depends entirely on what you count, the famous "2x within 24 hours" table traces to no primary source we could open, most feature lifts are correlations, the research on tiers and decoys is much weaker than the sales advice built on it, and the one thing you can rely on is your own funnel, counted with one stated definition.

Key takeaways

  • Vendor win-rate figures run from about 20% to 45% because they count different things. Proposify reports a 34% average close rate across 742,137 proposals sent in 2025, without defining "close", and sets it against an "industry average" of 20% that it does not source. Loopio's 2026 survey of 1,533 RFP professionals puts the RFP win rate at 39%, down from 45% the year before. RFP bids are not small-business quotes.
  • The "send within 24 hours and win 2x as often" claim, and the table that goes with it (50%, 43%, 30%, 18% by delay), did not trace to any primary page we could open. What exists is Better Proposals' report that proposals sent within 24 hours of the meeting "convert 23% better" (2021) and "42%" (2022), with conversion undefined, plus Proposify's 42.5%, which is the share of won deals closed within 24 hours of the customer opening the proposal, not a win rate.
  • Many quotes are simply not read quickly, or at all. In one vendor's sample of 8,162 proposals from 639 senders (DIGIDECK, 2018 to 2026), 26% were never opened, the median first open took about 52 hours, and 71% of those ever opened were opened within 7 days. Proposify's platform shows a 34-minute average to first open; the two measure different things and cannot be combined.
  • Feature lifts are correlations. Proposify's "3.3x more likely to close when the buyer watches the video" and "20% higher close rate with more than one viewer" describe deals that were already engaged. Its own data also show winning proposals were viewed 2.5 times on average against 3.5 for losing ones.
  • The decoy effect ("add a third, pricier option and the middle one sells") is much shakier than the sales advice built on it. Frederick, Lee and Baskin ran 19 studies with realistic stimuli and found no significant attraction effect in any; a large UK wine-purchase dataset found shifts of about 1%. We found no randomized field trial of good-better-best tiers in service quotes.
  • A higher first number moves the price people settle at, but it also raises walk-aways. A 2025 meta-analysis (374 effects from 90 studies; g = 0.42 comes from 80 of them) found a first-offer advantage of g = 0.42, and ambitious first offers caused more impasses and lower counterpart satisfaction. That describes negotiations, not a quote the customer can simply accept or decline.

What is a typical win rate for quotes and proposals?

It depends on the definition, and the published figures do not share one. The most visible is Proposify's State of Proposals 2026: "The average close rate of proposals sent through Proposify is 34%. The industry average close rate is only 20%." The page reports 742,137 proposals across 30 industries, worth $3.06 billion, sent through the platform in 2025. It does not define "close rate" and does not say where the 20% comes from.

The other number that circulates, 43%, belongs to a different thing. Loopio, an RFP-software company, surveyed 1,533 people involved in responding to RFPs, in partnership with the Association of Proposal Management Professionals (APMP), with the data analysed by Qualtrics. Its 2026 report says win rates "decreased to 39%", down from 45% last year. Its 2024 edition put the figure at 43% and the 2025 edition at 45%. These are formal RFP bids answered by proposal teams at companies of all sizes, not the quote a plumber, adviser or course creator sends after a call.

A third kind of figure comes from Better Proposals' CEO, in a guest post on Process Street: a "25.9% conversion rate" when a proposal is sent within 24 hours of making contact with a client, from what the post calls "over 189,000 successful business proposals" (its title says 180K). It has no comparison group and no definition of conversion, and because it counts only successful proposals it is unclear what the 25.9% is a share of. Put together, vendor figures span roughly 20% to 45%, and the gap is mostly a gap in what each counts: proposals sent, qualified opportunities or formal bids.

Published "win" figures, and what each one counts
Loopio: RFP win rate, previous year (self-reported survey)
45%
Loopio: RFP win rate, 2026 report
39%
Proposify: average close rate on its own platform (undefined)
34%
Better Proposals: "conversion" when sent within 24 hours (undefined)
25.9%
Proposify: "industry average" (no source given)
20%
Source: Loopio 2026 Trends Report (1,533 RFP professionals); Proposify State of Proposals 2026 (742,137 proposals sent in 2025); Process Street guest post by Better Proposals' CEO. Definitions differ by bar.

These bars are not one series: they mix RFP surveys, platform data and an undefined "conversion". Read them as a map of how far the definition moves the answer, not as a benchmark for your quotes.

Does sending a proposal within 24 hours really double your chances?

We could not find a primary source for it. A table is passed around that gives win rates by delay (50% or more under 24 hours, 43% at one to three days, 30% at four to seven, 18% beyond a week) alongside the line that proposals sent within 24 hours of an inquiry are "2x more likely to close". It circulates on third-party statistics roundups (for example Agiled), which credit the table to Proposify's 2024 State of Proposals and the "2x" line to PandaDoc. We looked for both on Proposify's current report, its best-practices article, Better Proposals' reports and the PandaDoc pages we could open, and found neither, and the roundup does not say what the "2x" is measured against. We would not repeat either.

What does exist is weaker and measures something else. Better Proposals' 2021 report says: "Proposals sent within 24 hours from talking to a client convert 23% better", up from 14% in 2019 and 19% in 2020, and that such proposals get signed in about 5 days on average. Its 2022 report says that sending within 24 hours of the meeting "increases conversion rates by 42%" and compares this to "last year's 27%", which does not match the 23% in the previous report. Neither page defines conversion or says whether "better" is a relative lift or percentage points, and the data come from the vendor's own users; the days-to-sign figure covers only deals that were signed.

A look-alike number is Proposify's 42.5%, from its proposal best-practices article: "42.5% of all closed-won proposals are won within 24 hours of opening." That is a share of wins, counted from the moment the customer opens the proposal, not from when it was sent, and it is not a win rate. It is easy to see how it turns into "43% win within 24 hours" in a blog post.

Better Proposals: reported figure for proposals sent within 24 hours of the meeting
2022 report
42%
2021 report
23%
2020
19%
2019
14%
Source: Better Proposals annual reports, 2021 (figures for 2019, 2020, 2021) and 2022. Conversion is not defined and the 2022 report's "last year's 27%" differs from the 2021 report's 23%.

Speed and winning travel together for plain reasons. Sellers who answer fast are usually better organised, and customers who are ready to buy answer fast too. These datasets cannot separate those from the effect of the speed itself. Note also that the 2021 report's text in that section lists 14%, 19% and 23% as a series ("to today's 23%"), so these may be conversion rates rather than lifts.

Is there real research behind "respond fast"?

There is, but it is about the first reply to an inquiry, not about when the quote arrives. The best-known academic work, a 2011 Harvard Business Review analysis by James Oldroyd, Kristina McElheran and David Elkington, looked at how quickly companies responded to online leads. Our article on speed to lead goes through what it and the later audits do and do not show, and why several of the best-known multipliers have shaky origins.

No study we found isolates the delay between a conversation and a quote. So the practical reading is modest: reply to the inquiry quickly, and send the quote while the customer's memory of the conversation is fresh and before a competitor's quote arrives. Both are sensible, and neither is supported by a trustworthy "2x".

How quickly do customers open a quote, and how many never do?

The two datasets that publish open times differ, because they measure different things. Proposify's 2026 report gives "34 minutes" for the "average time from when the proposal is sent until prospect opens it", and "2.5 days" for the average time from the first open to a closed-won deal. Both are averages over proposals sent on one platform, whose users are likely to be organised sellers (the second counts only deals that were won), and a mean is pulled around by a few very fast or very slow opens.

DIGIDECK, a proposal-tracking vendor, publishes a sample whose selection it does not describe: 8,162 proposals sent by 639 people at 29 organisations between 2018 and 2026, where a "read" counts only when someone opens two or more slides for at least ten seconds. In it, 23% of proposals were opened within 4 hours, 38% within 24 hours and 71% (of those ever opened) within 7 days, the median first open took about 52 hours, and 26% were never opened. DIGIDECK states the 71% as a share of proposals that were ever opened and gives no base for the 23% and 38%, so these figures cannot be summed with the 26%.

The sample is small and not representative, and DIGIDECK shows no win rate. Its main contribution is the idea that a sizeable share of proposals is simply not read, and that the first open is a real event in the life of a quote, whatever its average timing.

26%

of 8,162 proposals were never opened (DIGIDECK's own sample, which does not state the base for this figure; median first open about 52 hours). Proposify reports a 34-minute average to first open on its platform. The two are not comparable.

Source: DIGIDECK, best day and time to send a proposal (2018 to 2026 data); Proposify, State of Proposals 2026

When proposals were first opened, one vendor's sample (8,162 proposals)
Opened within 7 days (of those ever opened)
71%
Opened within 24 hours
38%
Never opened
26%
Opened within 4 hours
23%
Source: DIGIDECK, 639 senders at 29 organisations, 2018 to 2026. DIGIDECK gives the 71% as a share of proposals ever opened and states no base for the other bars, so do not add them up.

If your quote tool shows when a customer opened it, the useful signal is the gap between sent and first open for your own customers, and which quotes were never opened at all. Those are the ones to follow up by a different channel.

Do video, interactive pricing, more viewers and e-signatures lift close rates?

Vendors report that they do, with large multipliers, and each is a correlation. Proposify's 2026 report says: "When more than one stakeholder views your proposal, your close rate jumps by 20%"; "Companies that use interactive pricing win 2x more proposals and are 21% more likely to close"; "When a buyer watches your video, that proposal is 3.3x more likely to close"; and "Proposals that include e-signatures have a 15% higher close rate, and 60% faster speed to close, than those without."

None of these is an experiment. Companies that switch on interactive pricing differ from those that do not. A buyer who watches the video is already engaged. A second stakeholder who opens the proposal is a sign the deal is moving. The report does not say whether the percentages are relative or in points. One more detail from Proposify's own data points the other way: in an article first published in 2021, it reports that the average winning proposal was viewed 2.5 times before it closed, and the average losing one 3.5 times, because lost deals get more scrutiny.

Vendor claim (Proposify 2026)What it actually comparesWhy it cannot be read as cause and effect
More than one stakeholder views the proposal: close rate +20%Deals where a second person opened it versus deals where nobody else didA deal with several people involved is already live; an extra viewer is a symptom of progress
Interactive pricing: win 2x more proposals, 21% more likely to closeCompanies that use the feature versus those that do notSelection: organised, larger or better-fitting sellers adopt features. "2x more proposals" may be a count, not a rate
Buyer watches the video: 3.3x more likely to closeProposals where the video was played versus not playedPlaying the video happens after sending and signals interest, so it may be a result of the deal's strength
E-signature: 15% higher close rate and 60% fasterProposals with an e-signature versus withoutNot defined. What a proposal without e-signature is (printed, emailed PDF) is not stated

Reducing friction is still sensible. We found no dataset with a stated method that tests e-signature or fewer signing steps against quote completion, so there is no reliable number to give for it either way.

Do good-better-best options make customers accept more often?

The famous version is the decoy effect: add a third, asymmetrically worse option and the option it resembles gains share. It comes from lab studies, starting with Huber, Payne and Puto (1982), and from the compromise effect, where the middle option gains (Simonson, 1989). Sales advice built on these studies says to offer three tiers so the middle looks sensible.

The replications are not kind to it. Frederick, Lee and Baskin (Journal of Marketing Research, 2014) ran 19 studies with realistic stimuli, with sample sizes from 68 to 681 each, and found no significant attraction effect in any of them (one significant effect in the opposite direction appeared across its realistic-stimulus studies). The effect did appear when all the attributes were numbers, such as gambles. In the same issue, Yang and Lynn report 91 attempts across 23 product classes: only 11 produced reliable effects, significantly fewer than expected given the statistical power. Huber and colleagues published a rebuttal; we could not read it, so we do not describe its concessions.

The largest field evidence is observational. A 2025 paper in npj Science of Learning (Devine and co-authors) analysed about 3.6 million UK supermarket wine purchases by 755,158 customers, with 24,803 inferred choice sets. It found preference shifts of roughly 1%, strongly weaker among frequent buyers, in a setting of ordinary supermarket shoppers. We found no randomized field trial of tiered options in service quotes, where there are scope descriptions, a known provider and a customer who can negotiate. So the defensible claim is small: some buyers may use a middle option as a reference point, and we cannot say how much.

StudySettingFinding
Huber, Payne and Puto, 1982Lab choicesA dominated decoy can raise the share of the option that dominates it
Frederick, Lee and Baskin, JMR 201419 studies, N = 68 to 681 each, realistic stimuliNo significant attraction effect in any; one significant repulsion effect appeared across its realistic-stimulus studies; the effect appears when all attributes are numbers
Yang and Lynn, JMR 201491 attempts, 23 product classes, 73 decoyed choice setsOnly 11 reliable effects, fewer than expected given the statistical power
Devine and co-authors, npj Science of Learning 2025UK supermarket wine, about 3.6M purchases, observationalPreference shifts of about 1%, weaker among frequent buyers

None of these studies is a quote for a service. Treat a three-tier quote as a way to make scope choices clear, not as a proven conversion trick, and test it against your own acceptance rate.

Does a higher first price win more jobs?

A high first number does pull the final number up, and that is the problem with using it as a sales tactic. Petrowsky and co-authors (Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 2025) combined 374 effects from 90 studies with 16,334 participants and found a first-mover advantage of g = 0.42 (pooled from 80 of those effects), with the size of the first offer correlating with the agreed value (r = 0.62, 53 effects). The same analysis found that ambitious first offers caused more impasses (g = -0.42, only 13 effects) and lower satisfaction on the other side (g = -0.40, 41 effects). Two preregistered experiments with 2,121 participants replicated both patterns.

That is evidence about negotiations, where the other side counters. A customer comparing three quotes and choosing one is deciding accept or decline, and the study measures the price people settle at, not how often a quote is accepted. Nothing here shows that a higher quoted price wins more jobs. What it does show is the cost on the other side of the ledger: a first number set to leave room for negotiation also produces more walk-aways.

g = 0.42

first-mover advantage (g = 0.42) in a meta-analysis of 374 effects from 90 studies (16,334 participants), alongside more impasses and lower counterpart satisfaction for ambitious first offers

Source: Petrowsky and co-authors, Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 2025

Itemizing is a related question. Research found that splitting a price into parts can leave buyers recalling a lower total (Morwitz, Greenleaf and Johnson, 1998), and a later review organises the evidence around when and why the effect occurs. For a professional customer who adds up the lines, the total is what counts.

Should a quote have an expiry date?

The sales advice is to add a deadline to create urgency. The best field test we found points the other way, though it is not about quotes. In a randomized direct-mail experiment in South Africa (Bertrand, Karlan, Mullainathan, Shafir and Zinman, Quarterly Journal of Economics, 2010), a lender mailed 53,194 former clients loan offers that varied advertising content, price and deadline. Deadlines ran from about two to about six weeks, and the authors report that demand rose with longer deadlines, against the idea that a short deadline helps. The same study found that advertising content mattered about as much as sizeable changes in price.

That is consumer credit, not a service quote, and a newer set of experiments on online time-limited promotions (Hmurovic, Lamberton and Goldsmith, JMR 2023) found that they can trigger scepticism, with a reason outside the retailer's control helping. So a deadline that is real and explained is defensible, and an arbitrary one risks trust. In Israel there is also a legal reason to state the validity of a quote, covered next.

What does Israeli law say about a quote's validity and price?

A quote can be an "offer" in the legal sense, and the Contracts Law (General Part), 1973 sets the rules for how long it stays open. We read the statute text and describe it here; this is not legal advice, and how a court would treat a particular quote depends on its wording.

ProvisionWhat it says (our paraphrase)What it means for a quote
Contracts Law s.2An approach is an offer if it shows a firm intent to contract and is specific enough to be acceptedA vague "rough estimate" may not be an offer; a firm, specific quote is more likely to be one
Contracts Law s.8(א)An offer can be accepted only within the period set in it, and if none is set, within a reasonable timeWith no expiry, the window is "a reasonable time", which the law does not turn into a number of days. A stated period removes the ambiguity
Contracts Law s.3(ב) and s.4(1)If the offeror sets a date for acceptance, they cannot withdraw before it once the offer reached the other side; the offer lapses when the date passesA stated validity protects the customer's right to accept and also binds you until it ends
Contracts Law s.6(ב) and s.11An offeror cannot stipulate that the other side's silence counts as acceptance; an acceptance with changes is a new offerA customer who replies "yes, but at a lower price" has not accepted; they have made a new offer
Consumer Protection Law s.17דA business may not publish or state, expressly or by implication, a price for a good or service offered to a consumer unless it is the total price, in Israeli currencyA quote to a private customer should show the total including VAT. Business-to-business quotes often state a price plus VAT; we did not find a provision that requires otherwise between businesses

We found no court ruling on whether a tailored quote to an individual counts as stating a price under s.17ד, and we found no provision in the Consumer Protection Law that obliges a business to issue a quote at all (we did not review sector-specific rules). On signatures: s.3(א) of the Electronic Signature Law says a signature cannot be denied admissibility merely because it is electronic. Our e-signature article covers what the law requires.

What should a small business measure on its own quotes?

Pick one written definition and count each step against the same quotes, because your own funnel is the only evidence that describes your customers. Decide up front whether "win rate" means accepted quotes divided by quotes sent, or by qualified inquiries, and keep it for every month.

Here is the shape with invented numbers for 40 quotes sent in a month. The point is the order of magnitude of each step, not the values.

  • Read it two ways: 12 of 40 is a 30% win rate on quotes sent, but 12 of 32 is 37.5% of the quotes that were opened. The first measures the whole process, including quotes nobody read; the second measures the offer itself.
  • The 8 unopened quotes are a different problem from the 20 that were opened and not accepted. A reply on another channel can fix the first; a better offer, price or scope is the fix for the second.
  • Log the time from sent to accepted, and the quote's age when it was accepted. That tells you how long to wait before following up, and what validity period is realistic, from your own customers rather than from a vendor average.
  • Be realistic about testing. To detect a rise from a 30% to a 40% win rate with 80% power at the usual 5% significance level, you need about 356 quotes in each group; from 30% to 35%, about 1,380 per group (our calculation, standard two-proportion formula). A business sending 40 quotes a month cannot prove that a new template worked. Change one thing at a time, compare months only as a rough signal, and prefer changes with large expected effects.
Hypothetical month: 40 quotes sent (invented numbers)
Quotes sent
40
Opened (by the customer's own click or reply)
32
Customer asked a question or requested a change
14
Accepted
12
Source: Illustrative only, not data from any study or customer

Do not take a win rate from a vendor report as a target. Your own previous quarter, counted the same way, is the benchmark that matters.

How does oToK help with quotes?

oToK is a CRM, so the quote is created next to the customer's conversations, deals and payments rather than in a separate tool. Quotes with e-signature are included on every plan, with a monthly sending quota: 5 on Free, 50 on Growth, 250 on Pro and unlimited on Scale and Enterprise.

  • The customer gets a personal, branded quote page, sent by link or email, and signs on any device with no app and no account; the quote carries a validity date
  • A signed PDF with an audit certificate (the event trail with exact timestamps, in Hebrew and English), and an optional one-time-code check of the signer's identity per quote
  • Drafts, recalls and resends are not counted against the quota, so a mistake can be fixed and resent
  • Your legal issuer details are frozen onto each quote you send, and the customer's national ID or VAT number prints on it when you have it on file
  • A notification when a customer signs, and quotes sit on the contact's record next to the deal; automations can start from quote events
  • After acceptance you can collect or schedule payment through your own Cardcom or Sumit account (available on Scale and up)
  • Quotes sent and accepted are credited to the marketing touch that brought them in the attribution report (Growth and up), and the report builder includes a quotes dataset, so you can count your own funnel with one definition

None of this raises acceptance by itself. It makes the steps countable, keeps the quote, the signature and the payment in one record, and lets you compare one month with the next.

Share this article

Frequently asked questions

What is a good win rate for quotes and proposals?
There is no audited benchmark. Vendor figures run from about 20% to 45% and count different things: Proposify reports a 34% average close rate on its platform (742,137 proposals sent in 2025, close rate undefined), and Loopio's 2026 survey puts the RFP win rate at 39%, down from 45%. RFP bids are not small-business quotes. Your own previous quarter, counted with a fixed definition, is the useful benchmark.
Do proposals sent within 24 hours win twice as often?
We could not find a primary source for the "2x" claim or for the table of win rates by delay that accompanies it. Better Proposals reports that proposals sent within 24 hours of the meeting "convert 23% better" (2021 report) and "42%" (2022 report), without defining conversion. Proposify's 42.5% is the share of won deals closed within 24 hours of the customer opening the proposal, which is not a win rate.
How long does it take a customer to open a proposal?
It depends on how it is measured. Proposify reports an average of 34 minutes from send to first open on its platform in 2026. DIGIDECK, in a sample of 8,162 proposals, found a median of about 52 hours, with 38% opened within 24 hours and 26% never opened. The two use different definitions and samples, so they cannot be combined.
What percentage of proposals are never opened?
The only figure we found with a stated definition of a read is DIGIDECK's 26%, from 8,162 proposals sent by 639 people at 29 organisations between 2018 and 2026, where a read means two or more slides opened for at least ten seconds. It is a small vendor sample, so treat it as an indication that a meaningful share goes unread, not as an industry figure.
Does adding video or interactive pricing to a proposal increase close rate?
Proposify's 2026 report says proposals are 3.3x more likely to close when the buyer watches the video and that companies using interactive pricing win 2x more proposals and are 21% more likely to close. Those are comparisons of engaged or feature-adopting users with others, not experiments, so we cannot say the feature caused the lift.
Does offering three price tiers increase sales?
The evidence is weak. The decoy effect appears in some lab studies, but a 19-study replication with realistic stimuli found no significant attraction effect in any, another team found only 11 reliable effects in 91 attempts, and a large UK wine-purchase dataset found shifts of about 1%. We found no randomized field trial in service quotes. Tiers can make scope clear; do not count on them as a conversion trick.
Should a quote have an expiry date?
Under Israel's Contracts Law, an offer can be accepted within the period it sets, and if it sets none, within a reasonable time (s.8(א)), which the statute does not quantify. A stated period gives certainty and also binds you until it ends if the offer was delivered (s.3(ב)). The one field experiment we found, on consumer-credit mail, found demand rose with longer deadlines (two to six weeks).
Does a quote in Israel have to include VAT?
For a consumer, s.17ד of the Consumer Protection Law says a business may not publish or state, expressly or by implication, a price for a good or service offered to a consumer unless it is the total price, in Israeli currency, which includes VAT. We found no provision requiring VAT-inclusive prices between businesses, where a price plus VAT is common. Confirm with an accountant or lawyer for your case.
Does oToK send quotes with e-signature, and what does it cost?
Yes. Quotes with e-signature are included on every plan, Free included, with a monthly sending quota of 5 on Free, 50 on Growth, 250 on Pro and unlimited on Scale and Enterprise. The customer signs on a personal quote page with no app or account, and you get a signed PDF with an audit certificate. Collecting payment after acceptance through Cardcom or Sumit is available on Scale and up.

Ready to upgrade your customer communication?

Get started with oToK — connecting a WhatsApp number takes minutes.

No credit card required — start right away